What’s your problem? Help, the refrigerator destroyed my kitchen!

by Christopher Elliott on August 18, 2011

Question: My home was damaged when Sears installed a defective Whirlpool refrigerator in February.

Only hours after the technicians left, I found a large puddle of water extending out past the refrigerator into my kitchen.

I threw towels on the water and raced to the basement to turn off the valve for the water to the refrigerator. There was another puddle of water on the floor about 10 feet across. Water was running down the wall, and three ceiling tiles were broken, falling and hanging down with two more tiles with water stains.

Sears promised to not only fix the refrigerator, but also pay for all of the damage to my home. Although the company has repaired the refrigerator, it is dragging its feet on the damage, referring me to a Mexican valve manufacturer for a resolution.

Can you help me give Sears a little push to pay up? — Kathleen Pierz, Detroit

Answer: If Sears promised to cover the repair and damage, then it — not a Mexican valve manufacturer — should pay the bill.

I reviewed your correspondence with Sears, which was extensive. There’s a long trail of emails, phone calls and registered letters, some of which the company responds to with form letters, and some of which it ignores.

The best way to break such a deadlock is to appeal your case to a manager in writing. You might try sending an email directly to one of these folks.

I think you’ve been more than patient. The company needs to pay for the damage its refrigerator caused, and quickly.

I contacted Sears on your behalf, inquiring about the delay. It responded to you promptly, promising yet again to get to the bottom of the issue.

But instead of paying up, you received yet another letter from a claims management service, asking about the status of your claim. In comparing it with previous correspondence, it appeared to be a copy of another letter it had sent to you this spring.

Come on.

You sent a polite but firm response to the claims adjuster, saying that Sears had promised to fix the damage. Not Whirlpool or some Mexican valve manufacturer – Sears.

A Sears representative responded with an offer of $1,669, which covered the damage to your kitchen.

(Photo: Mario Sp ann/Flickr)

  • http://www.facebook.com/asiansm Dang Ph

    Next step, Sears will ask customers send the merchandises to China for repair or exchange.

  • Mbods2002

    Wow, I always liked Sears products but after reading this, it’s making me think twice.  I wonder when companies are going to catch on that when they engage in deceptive practices it’s not just a few people who find out about it…..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_LOCND3JAJL4PGYWJBHUT3HWAZM web/gadget guru

    The big problem here is that Sears is not the manufacturer of the fridge…so they don’t get much money on the sale of it…I bet, had this been a Kenmore fridge, there would have been a much different outcome!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OSY23WCTF4HVNVZEKPFLCHNVWU Axci

    Very simple.  Here in Florida small claims are handled up to $5,000.  Simply file a small claims suit against Sears and see how quick they will pay the damages and the filing fees.

  • Dlynne30

    I purchased a Kenmore stacked washer and dryer from Sears in March 2011. Sears technicians improperly installed the washer which nine months later caused a bolt to come loose and make (It was still under warranty.) This resulted in the washer flooding my home.  Three weeks later another Sears technican came out to “repair” the washer – the parts had previously been UPSed to me.  Ten minutes after technicians left, the washer once again flooded my a hole in the bottom of the washer.  I filed a claim with Sedgewick (Sears insurance company), as I already lost a deductible from the first claim through my own home insurance.  Was this the right thing to do with this second incident?

  • Searshomesucks

    If you or someone you know has had home improvement projects by Sears, please visit this website http://www.searshomesucks.com

Previous post:

Next post: